Home Kitchen

Ice cream sandwich maker – the perfect summer companion

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

If you have a sweet tooth and you like to do experiments with different recipes at home, ice cream sandwich can take care of your cravings. A sweet treat that always brings joy to people of all ages. 

In this article, we have covered everything there is to know about buying the best ice cream sandwich maker. So just read ahead, look forward to some cravings and get ready for an exciting read. 

Editor's Pick

4.9/5

Cuisipro Mini

☞ Weight: 4.00 ounces
☞ Material: Plastic

What to look for in an ice cream sandwich maker?

As it is a relatively new thing, most of the people do not know what to look for in an ice cream sandwich maker. The following guide will help in learning a little more about it.

Ease of Use

Ease of use is the most important thing that you should consider, especially if you are buying it for home use. If it is difficult to use, you will lose your interest halfway through. 

Some machines are expensive, but they still have the highest demand. That is all because they are easy to use. You do not have to do much work with these types of machines. Even the kids can make their favorite ice cream sandwiches all by themselves.

In contrary to that, some machines are less expensive but can make your life very difficult.

Cost

Now, the thing that will confuse you the most in buying the best ice cream sandwich maker is the major price difference between its different types. 

Some are expensive, but they come with their perks. They will pace up the process of making ice cream sandwiches while being consistent with the type of end product they produce.

In contrary to that, simple machines are also available in the market.  But they will demand a lot of hard work.
Price is usually determined by the ease of use, durability, and consistency it provides. 

Taste and Texture

It might not be the case with other types of desserts, but with ice cream sandwiches, the texture contributes a lot to its taste. In addition to that, a good textured sandwich is very eye-catching, and you could attract your kids into eating it.  

Try buying the one that will allow you to experiment with different shapes and textures.

Durability

Ice cream sandwich makers that are available in the market are made up of different material types. Some of the material types are more durable than others. Always choose a machine that is made of durable and reliable material.

Quantity

Ice cream sandwich makers come in different types. Simple machines allow making only one sandwich at a time, while you can make more than one sandwich with the more expensive ones. 

It is for you to decide, which quantity suits you the best.

List of the top 8 best ice cream sandwich makers:

ImageNameFeaturesRatingPrice
Cuisipro Mini☞ Weight: 4.00 ounces
☞ Material: Plastic
4.9/5View Product
Silikomart BISC03☞ Weight: 1.61 pounds
☞ Material: silicone, plastic
4.8/5View Product
Wilton Nonstick☞ Weight: 1.45 pounds
☞ Material: nonstick coating
4.7/5View Product
Norpro☞ Weight: 12.8 ounces
☞ Material: BPA Free Plastic
4.6/5View Product
The Pampered Chef☞ Weight: 6.1 ounces
☞ Material: Plastic
4.7/5View Product
Tovolo Classic☞ Weight: 2.56 ounces
☞ Material: Plastic
4.8/5View Product
Evriholder i’Scream Silicone☞ Weight: 3.98 ounces
☞ Material: BPA Free materials
4.8/5View Product
Cuisipro White☞ Weight: 10.4 ounces
☞ Material: Plastic, Metal
4.7/5View Product

1. Cuisipro Mini- best ice cream sandwich maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 4.00 ounces
  •  Material: Plastic

Making ice cream sandwiches at home can never be as easy as it gets with this product. The product helps you make ice cream sandwiches by using simple grocery items. So, you will not have to spend money on fancy items and still be able to make unlimited combinations of sandwiches. 

The product is easy to use. It allows you to make one sandwich at a time. With this machine, you can make ice cream sandwiches in three different shapes that are circle, star, and heart. With all the shape options, making sandwiches can be very enjoyable, especially for kids.

The maker is made up of BPA free plastic and does not have any sharp edges. The product is completely safe for you and the kids. It takes about 2 to 1 and ½ inch sized cookies which can be a tab bit tiny for some people. 

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Allows you to make sandwiches in three different shapes
  • Made up of BPA free plastic
Cons
  • 1 or 1 and ½ inch cookie

2. Silikomart BISC03 – top-selling ice cream sandwich maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 1.61 pounds
  • Material: silicone, plastic

Out of all the products on the list, this one is the most expensive. It has identical 6-cavity silicone molds which allow you to make multiple sandwiches at a time. It is ideal for hosting different parties at home. You will not have to go through the tiring process of making one sandwich at a time.

Silicone molds have a temperature resistance of -60 to 230C. The sandwiches made through this maker are easy to store. Once you are done making the sandwiches, you could either eat them right away or you can also store them for later use.

Its identical molds restrict you from making only one shape of sandwiches.

Pros
  • The 6-cavity mold allows you to make 6 sandwiches at a time
  • Excellent results
Cons
  • Offers only one shape

3. Wilton Nonstick 12-Cavity – Durable ice cream sandwich maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 1.45 pounds
  • Material: nonstick coating

You can make amazing small little rectangular sandwiches with this one. It allows you to make 12 sandwiches simultaneously, which saves a lot of time.

The best thing about the product is that it has a non-stick pan. Your brownies will not stick with to the surface and you will be able to release them quite easily. You should grease the pan to get the best result.

The product is dishwasher safe which makes the cleaning process much easier. It is made of high-quality material, which ensures the product’s durability.

It is a multi-purpose product and is not restricted to making ice-cream sandwiches. You can make quite a lot of desserts with this product.

Pros
  • Allows you to make 12 sandwiches at a time
  • Non-sticky pan
  • Durable
  • Multi-purpose
Cons
  • Not very deep

4. Norpro- BPA free Ice Cream Sandwich Maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 12.8 ounces
  •  Material: BPA Free Plastic

The Norpro Ice Cream Sandwich Maker allows you to make amazing sandwiches, from the comfort of your home. May it be birthdays, anniversaries, or house parties this product can be very handy to make traditional ice cream sandwiches.

Since it is made with very fine BPA free plastic, it is highly durable. It lets you cut the perfect ice cream sandwich with great consistency through its built-in sandwich cutter. Its limitation is that it allows you to make sandwiches of only one shape i.e. rectangle.

The product comes with a detailed user manual. In addition to that, it provides you with perfect recipes so you could experiment with different kinds of sandwiches.

Pros
  • Makes sandwiches with great consistency
  • Comes with detailed user instructions
  • BPA free plastic
Cons
  • Doesn’t allow you to play with different shapes and textures

5. The Pampered Chef #2485 – Expensive ice cream sandwich maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 6.1 ounces
  • Material:  Plastic

It contains everything you need to make a perfect ice cream sandwich. The product gives you total control over your sandwiches. You can decide what exactly goes into your sandwiches i.e. low-fat cookies, frozen yogurt, etc.  

Making ice cream sandwiches at home is usually a very fun activity, especially for kids. They can enjoy experimenting with different recipes, flavors, and textures. The product is completely safe with kids due to its edgeless material. Once you know how to use it, you can let your kids try it.

The product comes with very poor instructions. Most of the users have given it away just because they could not find a way of using it. If you have never owned an ice cream sandwich maker before, this product may be confusing for you.

Pros
  • Gives control over your sandwiches
  • Kids have a fun time using it
Cons
  • Comes with poor instructions
  • Expensive

6. Tovolo Classic – High walled design

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 2.56 ounces
  • Material: Plastic

Tovolo makes the ice cream sandwich-making process quite simple. You just need to bake the cookie, mold it according to your shape through the cutter, and finally press it down. And you are ready to serve delicious ice cream sandwiches.

Its high walled design is quite efficient as it allows maximum filling. The product offers two patterns that are dots and diamonds. You can choose whichever pattern you like. 

It is made from environmental-friendly BPA plastic. The material is quite sturdy and durable. The product is dishwasher safe, which makes it an easy to clean product. 

Pros
  • High walled design
  • Offers dot and diamond pattern
  • Durable material
Cons
  • Allows making rectangular sandwiches only

7. Evriholder i’Scream Silicone – Ease to use ice cream sandwich maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 3.98 ounces
  • Material: BPA Free materials

The product comes in three different colors that are green, red, and blue respectively. This is one of the easiest to use. You and your kids can have a fun time making your favorite ice cream sandwiches with this. You can refrigerate the sandwiches for later use, as well.

It is made from BPA free plastic which ensures food safety. Right after making the sandwiches and enjoying them, cleaning is usually the most tiring process. With this product, you don’t have to worry about that. You can easily put it in a dishwasher as it is dishwasher safe.

Kids usually love mixing and matching different ice-cream flavors and creating their treat. The product will allow your kids to do that. But the kids wouldn’t be able to play with different shapes and textures as it allows making sandwiches of only one shape.

Pros
  • Comes in three different colors
  • Ease to use
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Only one shape

8. Cuisipro White – Dishwasher safe Ice-Cream Sandwich Maker

Check Price On Amazon

Key features:

  • Weight: 10.4 ounces
  • Material:  Plastic, Metal

Another Cuisipro product makes it into our list. The first one was to make mini ice cream sandwiches. This one allows you to make full-fledged ice cream sandwiches. 

It is made up of highly durable plastic which makes the product quite sturdy. Cleaning is very easy, as it is dishwasher safe. And the most important thing is that it comes with instructions that are very helpful for using this product.

The included recipes are tried and tested. You just need to follow them, and you are ready to serve the best ice cream sandwiches to your friends and family. 

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Highly durable material
  • Included recipes are tried and tested
Cons
  • Allows only triangular ice cream sandwiches

Conclusion:

Ice cream sandwiches are fun to make and delicious to eat. With the right ice cream sandwich maker, your overall experience will be fun and easy. Choosing the right product, however, can be a difficult task. But do not worry, choose the product that suits you the best and make ice cream sandwiches at home without the need of buying them from expensive ice cream parlors.

FAQs:

  1. What is the proper way to package an ice cream sandwich?
    Parchment paper and wax paper are usually used to package an ice cream sandwich.  Some people also use plastic wraps, but they are not very environmental-friendly.
  2. Is Ice Cream Sandwich unhealthy?
    An average ice cream sandwich contains 3.5g of fat, 29 carbs, and 15g of sugar. So, it is not bad for you. But if you are health conscious and are on a diet, avoid eating too much at a time.
  3. How long do homemade ice cream sandwiches last?
    Properly wrapping and refrigerating them could make them last up to 2 weeks. 
  4. Can you refreeze ice cream sandwiches?
    Yes, but it is unsafe to refreeze the melted ice cream sandwich. However, if it is still cold and is not melted properly, refreezing them would not be harmful.
  5. How many sandwiches can be made with an ice cream sandwich maker?
    Ice cream sandwich makers are of different types. Simple machines allow making only one sandwich at a time, while you can make more than one sandwich in the expensive ones. 
  6. Is the texture of an ice cream sandwich important?
    Yes, it might not be the case with other types of desserts, but with ice cream sandwiches, the texture contributes a lot to its taste. In addition to that, good, textured sandwiches are very eye-catching, and you could attract your kids into eating it.

Comments are closed.